CMHC vs Conventional Construction Financing: A Builder’s Guide [2025]

CMHC construction financing stands out with its reduced premiums and longer amortization periods, particularly for rental apartment projects focusing on affordability and sustainability. On the other hand, conventional construction financing offers greater flexibility across various project types, including retail, condominiums, and industrial buildings. While CMHC typically provides lower interest rates, it comes with specific requirements for affordability, accessibility, and energy efficiency that developers must meet.

This guide examines the key differences between CMHC and conventional construction financing, helping developers make an informed decision based on their project goals, timeline, and financial capabilities.

Understanding Construction Financing Basics

Construction financing serves as a specialized short-term loan designed specifically for building new residential or commercial properties. Unlike traditional mortgages, these loans typically last for 12 months or less and provide funds in stages rather than as a lump sum payment.

What is Construction Financing?

Construction financing enables builders to cover various project costs, specifically contractor labor, building materials, and necessary permits. The distinguishing feature of these loans lies in their disbursement structure – lenders release funds in predetermined stages called “draws” based on construction milestones. Furthermore, during the construction phase, borrowers generally make interest-only payments rather than full principal and interest payments.

Interest rates for construction loans generally run 1% to 5% higher than conventional mortgage rates, primarily because these loans carry more risk for lenders since there’s no existing property to serve as collateral.

Key Terms Every Builder Should Know

Understanding essential construction financing terminology helps navigate the lending process effectively:

• Draw Schedule: A detailed payment plan agreed upon by the contractor, client, and lender that outlines when funds will be released during construction.
• Construction-to-Permanent Loan: A financing option that automatically converts into a regular mortgage once construction completes, requiring only one closing process.
• Certificate of Occupancy: Written authorization from local municipalities permitting occupancy of a newly constructed building.
• Interest Reserves: A portion of borrowed funds specifically allocated for paying loan interest to the lender during construction.
• Retainage: A percentage of funds withheld by lenders with each draw as a precautionary measure against project risks.

Most lenders require a minimum down payment of 20%, although some may demand up to 25%. Additionally, borrowers must provide comprehensive project documentation, specifically detailed construction plans, realistic budgets, and contractor credentials. Lenders also conduct regular inspections throughout the construction process, typically performing between four to six site visits to monitor progress and approve subsequent draws.

CMHC Construction Financing Deep Dive

The CMHC MLI Select program offers builders innovative financing solutions through a points-based system that rewards social and environmental commitments. This program stands as a cornerstone of CMHC’s efforts to support rental housing construction across Canada.

MLI Select Program Requirements

The program evaluates projects based on three key criteria: affordability, energy efficiency, and accessibility. Builders must achieve a minimum of 50 points across these categories. Projects earning higher points unlock enhanced benefits:

• 70+ points: Access to 45-year amortization periods
• 100+ points: Qualify for limited-recourse financing and 50-year amortization

Premium Rates and Incentives

CMHC provides substantial financial advantages through MLI Select:

• Loan-to-cost ratios reaching 95% for residential components
• Reduced debt coverage ratios of 1.10 for standard rental housing
• Discretionary replacement reserve requirements based on borrower strength

For frequent builders with proven track records, moreover, CMHC offers expedited loan approvals and underwriting flexibilities. Qualifying builders must demonstrate a minimum of CAD 69.67 million in CMHC business.

Project Eligibility Criteria

Projects seeking CMHC financing must meet specific requirements:

• Minimum project size of 5 rental units
• Loan amounts starting at CAD 1.39 million
• Non-residential components limited to 30% of total gross floor space and cost

The affordability commitment requires maintaining rent levels below market rates for at least 10 years. Projects must ensure either 20% of units have rents below 30% of median total income or establish rents through an approved affordable housing program.

Energy efficiency standards mandate a minimum 15% improvement over applicable building codes. Accessibility requirements stipulate that 10% of units must meet or exceed local accessibility standards, with barrier-free access to common areas.

Conventional Construction Loan Analysis

Conventional construction financing presents builders with flexible options across diverse project types. Lenders evaluate applications based on comprehensive criteria, ensuring project viability and risk management.

Typical Lender Requirements

Securing conventional construction financing demands stringent qualifications. Lenders typically require a credit score of at least 700, surpassing the threshold for standard mortgages. Applicants must submit detailed construction plans, architectural designs, and comprehensive budgets.

Most financial institutions mandate working with qualified builders or contractors. This requirement helps mitigate construction risks and ensures professional project execution. Lenders thoroughly assess the borrower’s financial stability through:

• Income verification documentation
• Employment history records
• Current debt obligations analysis
• Asset statements

Interest Rate Structures

Interest rates for conventional construction loans consistently exceed traditional mortgage rates. This premium reflects the heightened risk associated with financing incomplete properties. Construction loan rates typically range between 1% to 5% above standard mortgage rates.

Several factors influence rate determination:

• Current market conditions
• Borrower’s creditworthiness
• Project timeline
• Loan amount
• Construction type

Throughout the building phase, most lenders permit interest-only payments, offering financial flexibility as developers manage construction costs.

Equity Requirements

Conventional construction financing necessitates substantial equity participation. Lenders commonly require down payments ranging from 20% to 30% of the total project cost. This requirement exceeds CMHC-insured options by approximately 15%.

The equity structure varies based on:

• Project value assessment
• Land ownership status
• Developer’s track record
• Construction type
• Market conditions

Developers owning land outright might leverage it as equity, potentially borrowing up to 75% of the project’s appraised value. Some lenders extend financing up to 95% of construction costs for borrowers with exceptional credit profiles and consistent income streams.

Execution speed emerges as another crucial consideration, as conventional financing typically offers faster processing compared to insured alternatives. This advantage enables developers to commence projects promptly, maintaining construction schedules effectively.

Cost Comparison and ROI Analysis

Financial analysis reveals significant differences between CMHC and conventional construction financing options, impacting both immediate costs and long-term returns for developers.

Initial Setup Costs

The upfront investment requirements mark a notable distinction between these financing paths. Conventional construction loans demand higher equity participation, typically requiring down payments between 25% to 30% of the total project cost. Conversely, CMHC-backed financing enables developers to secure funding with lower initial equity requirements.

For larger projects, CMHC’s Frequent Builder framework offers substantial advantages. Developers managing portfolios exceeding CAD 1.39 billion in multi-residential assets or maintaining a minimum net worth of CAD 348.34 million qualify for expedited approvals and enhanced flexibility.

The application process itself carries varying costs. Conventional financing often provides faster turnaround times, nonetheless CMHC financing includes integrated mortgage loan insurance without premium costs to borrowers.

Long-term Financial Impact

Development yield metrics highlight crucial differences in long-term profitability. Cash-on-Cash Return calculations demonstrate how CMHC financing’s lower equity requirements can enhance returns. Subsequently, the Internal Rate of Return (IRR) benefits from reduced debt payments through CMHC programs.

Market research indicates shifting preferences in investment horizons. Presently, 65% of developers favor investment periods under 10 years. This trend influences financing choices, as conventional loans offer more flexibility for shorter-term projects.

Recent data shows that 85% of rental developers face challenges obtaining project funding. In response, 95% now consider CMHC funding or insurance products. The financial landscape has evolved to where nine out of ten respondents indicate purpose-built rental projects are no longer feasible with conventional debt financing alone.

For a practical example, consider a two-bedroom rental apartment valued at CAD 696,680. Under recent policy changes, developers can receive tax relief of CAD 34,834 through GST rebates, further impacting the long-term cost analysis between financing options.

Comparison Table

Conclusion

Canadian developers face a critical choice between CMHC and conventional construction financing, each offering distinct advantages for different project types and goals. CMHC financing stands out with its lower equity requirements – as little as 5% compared to the 20-30% demanded by conventional lenders. Though CMHC programs require specific commitments to affordability, energy efficiency, and accessibility, they reward these commitments with favorable terms like extended amortization periods and reduced premium rates.

Conventional financing offers greater flexibility and faster processing times, making it suitable for developers who prioritize quick project launches or need financing for non-residential components exceeding 30% of the total space. Additionally, developers with strong credit profiles might find conventional loans advantageous despite higher interest rates, especially for shorter-term projects.

Recent market data shows 85% of rental developers struggle with project funding, while 95% now consider CMHC options. These statistics highlight the growing importance of understanding both financing paths. 

Ultimately, the choice between CMHC and conventional construction financing depends on specific project parameters, timeline requirements, and long-term investment goals. Successful developers carefully evaluate their project’s unique characteristics against each financing option’s requirements and benefits before making this crucial decision.

Book a free consultation with our expert today and get personalized insights on securing financing for your development projects.

👉 Schedule your free consultation now

FAQs

Q1. What are the main differences between CMHC and conventional construction financing?

CMHC financing offers lower equity requirements (as low as 5%) and reduced interest rates, but comes with specific affordability, energy efficiency, and accessibility requirements. Conventional financing provides more flexibility and faster processing times but typically requires 20-30% down payment and higher interest rates.

Q2. What type of construction loan is most advantageous for builders?

Construction-to-permanent loans are often the most advantageous as they automatically convert into mortgages upon project completion. This single-close option helps builders avoid duplicate closing costs and simplifies the financing process.

Q3. Does CMHC offer specific programs for rental housing construction?

Yes, CMHC provides the Apartment Construction Loan Program, which offers low-cost financing to support the construction of standard rental housing and the conversion of non-residential properties into rental units.

Q4. What benefits does CMHC’s Frequent Builder framework provide?

The Frequent Builder framework accelerates the construction of affordable rental homes by expediting the application process for established housing providers with a proven track record. This makes the process easier and faster for qualified developers.

Q5. How do equity requirements differ between CMHC and conventional construction financing?

CMHC financing can require as little as 5% equity (up to 95% loan-to-cost ratio), while conventional construction financing typically demands a 20-30% down payment. This significant difference in equity requirements can greatly impact a developer’s initial investment and project feasibility.